Frequently Asked Questions
QUESTIONS BY END CONSUMERS
1. Why is it important to consider peat-free or peat-reduced growing media?
Globally, peat still represents the most commonly used raw material for growing media. However, its use is associated with high greenhouse gas emissions, primarily due to decomposition processes that occur when peat is used as a substrate component. As a result, peat generally has a higher carbon footprint compared to alternative products.
Peat is extracted from drained peatlands. In Germany, most of this drainage took place during the 19th and 20th centuries to make the land usable for agriculture. However, intact or restored peatlands play a crucial role in climate protection, as they can store up to six times more carbon than forests of the same area. At the same time, they serve as vital habitats for many rare animal and plant species and make a significant contribution to preserving biodiversity.
For these reasons, the German government’s Climate Action Program 2030 aims to phase out the use of peat in hobby gardening by 2026 and to largely reduce its use in the professional horticultural sector by 2030.
You can find more information on peatland protection here.
2. How does HORTICERT promote the sustainability of peat substitutes and growing media?
Peat causes higher CO₂eq emissions than most peat substitutes. By choosing a peat-free or peat-reduced growing medium, you can directly contribute to reducing greenhouse gas emissions. But how is the sustainability of peat substitutes — such as green compost, wood fibers, or coconut-based products — verified? This is where the HORTICERT certification system comes in.
HORTICERT assesses the ecological, social, and economic sustainability of peat substitutes across the entire value chain. This includes, for example, the protection of ecologically valuable areas, environmentally friendly production methods and compliance with human and labor rights. These requirements are audited by independent certification bodies.
Furthermore, the HORTICERT methodology for calculating greenhouse gas emissions enables transparent, verifiable, and comparable data on emission reductions from the peat-free or peat-reduced growing medium, measured against a reference mixture made of 100 percent peat. Another important element at HORTICERT is the traceability of supply chains. This helps to confirm that sustainability requirements are met throughout the production process and that only sustainably produced and certified quantities are marketed as such.
3. How can I recognise HORTICERT-certified potting soil?
HORTICERT-certified products are labelled by a logo. This logo confirms that a product meets HORTICERT’s requirements for sustainability, supply chain traceability and carbon footprint calculation.
The logo can be framed with different claims, thus further statements about the product. In this way the greenhouse gas savings of the product in comparison with a peat-based reference product can be indicated. Additional information for the consumer is accessible for example on the back of the product packaging or via a QR-code. In this way, the HORTICERT logo helps consumers make environmentally friendly and informed purchasing decisions. More information about our logos and claims can be found here.
4. Are coconut-based peat substitutes genuinely more sustainable than peat?
Coconut-based peat substitutes (such as coir pith, fiber, and chips) are playing an increasingly important role in the growing media industry. Since these products are typically imported from countries such as India and Sri Lanka, concerns are often raised about their carbon footprint. However, despite the long transport distances, the emissions per ton are significantly lower than those of trucks over the same distance, thanks to the high cargo capacity of ships. Moreover, the processing of coconut husks into peat substitutes is usually resource-efficient, often using rainwater and solar energy. While transportation accounts for a substantial portion of total greenhouse gas emissions, research indicates that coconut-based peat substitues are still associated with lower emissions than peat.
However, when cultivating and processing coconut-based peat substitutes, social and environmental aspects must also be considered. These include fair working conditions, workplace safety, and the correct and safe application of fertilizers. The HORTICERT certification system for sustainable peat substitutes monitors these and other sustainability requirements throughout the entire supply chain. This allows consumers to trust that coconut-based peat substitutes have been produced sustainably – ecologically, socially and economically. For more information, please refer to our Coconut Factsheet.
5. Does HORTICERT also cover quality aspects of peat substitutes and growing media?
No, HORTICERT solely focuses on the sustainability of growing media and the peat substitutes they contain. Quality aspects can be covered by other schemes on the market – such as RAL Gütezeichen or RHP.
6. How does HORTICERT provide integrity of the certification?
To ensure the integrity of HORTICERT, the HORTICERT requirements are reviewed by auditors from independent certification bodies (CBs) as part of annual audits. Such a third-party verification is essential for the transparency and credibility of the certification system. Auditors must successfully complete an auditor training in order to be eligible to conduct HORTICERT certification audits.
Audits are then carried out according to a risk-based approach. This means that particular emphasis is placed on aspects where the auditor has identified a high risk as part of the mandatory risk assessment prior to the audit. Both the audit report and the certification decision are reviewed by HORTICERT before the certificate is issued to the system user. Unannounced surveillance audits may take place within the validity period of the certificate.
In addition, HORTICERT will develop an integrity programme to further strengthen the consistency, objectivity and reliability of audits and certification processes. This will be a tool to enable closer monitoring of the CB’s auditing and certification activities and companies’ compliance with HORTICERT requirements through integrity assessments, which include assessments of CB offices and HORTICERT certificate holders on a random or targeted basis following risk evaluations or complaints.
QUESTIONS BY SYSTEM USERS AND CERTIFICATION BODIES
1. How can I ensure a seamless HORTICERT certification?
A HORTICERT certificate is valid for one year and therefore requires annual recertification audits. There can be a maximum period of 60 days between the audit and the issue of the new certificate, during which the system user can rectify any non-conformities and the auditor can finalise the audit report. To ensure seamless HORTICERT certification, the date for recertification must therefore be set in good time.
2. Can freelance auditors also conduct a HORTICERT audit?
Yes, as long as the auditor works for a certification body recognised by HORTICERT and has successfully completed the HORTICERT auditor training, a HORTICERT audit can also be conducted by a freelance auditor. Learn more about certification bodies here.